A Heat Pump Comparison of Trane Vs Goodman: Fair and Simplified

When evaluating heat pumps and other air conditioning equipment, homeowners require real facts and unbiased product comparison data. Nobody wants to read a skewed A/C comparison study in which one brand is preferred over the other simply because the installer has stronger ties to that particular and heat pump company. 

Serious purchasers need a fair and balanced report explaining which HVAC system is ideal for home climate, housing type, and budget. Search for heat pumps for sale near me for the best services by our professionals.

The units below are comparable in terms of quality and features. Perhaps this information can assist you in making an informed decision on the purchase, replacement, or upgrading of your home air conditioning system.

The Comparison of the Trane XL20i with the Goodman DSXC18

  • External communication 

It allows you to access your air conditioning settings using a dial-up modem. This function is available on both the Trane XL20i and the Goodman DSXC18.

  • Humidity Control 

It allows a heat pump or condensing unit’s fan to run at a slower speed. This function aids the evaporator coil in removing more moisture from your home. Thanks to the Trane Comfort RTM controller, this capability is available on the XL20i. Goodman’s equally excellent counterpart returns to the DSXC18. Both devices require the condenser and air handler to be installed as a matched pair for proper operation.

  • Two-Stage Cooling

With both systems, two-stage cooling is available. The Trane XL20i comes with two Trane Dual Climatuff® Compressors, whereas the Goodman DSXC18 uses a single compressor that operates two-stage to accomplish the same duty.

  • Charge Assist 

It allows your expert to ensure your Phoenix home heat pump is properly charged for maximum efficiency. This function is exclusive to the XL20i and may assist the technician in keeping your system running smoothly.

  • Multi-Stage Fan

The system condenser fan motor and the system blower motor may run more efficiently with the Multi-Stage Fan. Trane and Goodman both provide multi-stage fan/variable speed condenser and ECM blower motor controllers that are compatible.

  • Condenser Coil Construction

Goodman uses copper with aluminum fins in condenser coils, whereas Trane uses an all-aluminum Two-row Spine FinTM system. While both systems are efficient, some technicians prefer full aluminum, while others prefer copper with aluminum fins.

  • SEER Ratings

Both systems have Energy Star ratings, with the Trane XL20i getting up to 20 SEER and the Goodman DSXC18 getting up to 18. Inquire with your ACH technician about any other SEER variances between the units.

  • Enhanced Diagnostics

It can assist an A/C professional in identifying a problem more rapidly. However, just like a car’s computer system, an HVAC improved diagnostics system has its limits. This characteristic is listed as a “one-of-a-kind” value by Goodman.

  • Common Components

The usage of R-410A refrigerant, a weather-resistant cabinet structure, and a product intended for silent operation are all common components. The DuraTuffTM Rust Proof base pan from Trane is a step forward, but it’s not a deal-breaker.

In terms of fundamental features, and efficiency, either of these devices is a terrific bargain. A buyer can find some unique things for each unit in an apartment. In case you have stumbled upon the Goodman product. You need any services associated with it, search for Goodman HVAC distributors near me for the top-notch service by our employees. 

Still undecided on which system to install? Consider contacting us at Hvac Warehouse via mail or give us a call. You may also inquire about a pricing estimate for any cooling and air quality services by contacting our specialists. 

Scroll to Top